Choice In Recovery

By Bees | January 13, 2026

Plain cardboard box with beautiful paint colors bursting from the top to represent LifeRing meetings supporting multiple paths to recoveryOut of the Box

Beyond the 12 Steps: Embracing a "Many Paths" Approach to Recovery

For decades, the standard narrative of addiction recovery has been synonymous with the 12-step model. Many treatment centers present it not just as an option, but as the only option. However, as the landscape of recovery evolves, we are realizing a fundamental truth: Recovery is an intensely personal voyage, and one size does not fit all.

If you’ve ever felt that the traditional approach didn't quite "click" for you, you aren't alone — and you aren't failing. It’s time to think "out of the box" about what peer support really looks like.

The Myth of the "Only Way"

For many, the core tenets of the 12 steps — such as surrendering to a higher power or admitting total powerlessness—can feel like a barrier rather than a bridge. For those who identify as atheist, agnostic, without a religious affiliation, or simply prefer a self-empowerment framework, these requirements can lead to a sense of isolation during an already difficult time.

 

The goal is not to find the 'best' program,
but the program that is best for you.

The good news? Research supports a more inclusive view. For years, the 12-step model was treated as the gold standard, but the 2018 groundbreaking Peer Alternatives Study provided evidence that success isn't tied to a single philosophy. The study reveals that secular and self-empowerment-based groups — including LifeRing, SMART Recovery and Women for Sobriety — are equally effective as AA. This research validates the experiences of countless individuals who have found lasting freedom through diverse methods, proving that whether you prefer a spiritual foundation, a cognitive-behavioral approach, or a secular community, your chosen path is a scientifically sound route to a healthier life.

A Toolkit of Diverse Support Groups

Finding the right fit is about matching a program’s philosophy with your personal values. Here are six major peer support groups that offer unique perspectives on the journey to wellness:

  • 12-Steps: Emphasizes a higher power, sponsorship, and a structured 12-step process.  with various meeting formats catering to different demographics.
  • LifeRing Secular Recovery: Focus on the "sober self" vs. the "addictive self" with an emphasis on self-empowerment and individualized recovery plans.
  • Recovery Dharma: A Buddhist-based approach emphasizing inner wisdom, self-empowerment, and compassion, with a focus on both substance use and process addictions.
  • She Recovers Foundation: Supporting women in recovery from various challenges, promoting individualized pathways to recovery without criticizing any approach.
  • SMART Recovery: Utilizing cognitive behavioral therapy techniques and catering to a wide range of behavioral disorders; not exclusively abstinence-based
  • Women for Sobriety: Empowering women to take charge of their lives, create new self-images, and utilize positive reinforcement techniques.

Why Choice Matters

We live in a diverse society where an increasing number of people prefer secular or self-empowered approaches to health. By opening the door to multiple pathways, we remove the "barrier to entry" for recovery.

Effective treatment of addiction is individualized. The National Institute of Drug Abuse (NIDA) of the National Institute of Mental Health (NIMH) conducted a comprehensive study of treatment methods and found, as the first fundamental principle:

No single treatment is appropriate for all individuals.
Matching treatment settings, interventions, and services to each individual's particular problems and needs is critical to [their] ultimate success in returning to productive functioning in the family, workplace, and society.

— Principles of Drug Addiction Treatment: A Research-Based Guide
National Institute on Drug Abuse (NIA), January 2014

When an individual is empowered to choose a method that resonates with their worldview, their engagement increases — and so do their chances of long-term success. Whether you find strength in spirituality, science, mindfulness, or community-specific empowerment, your path is valid.

The goal is not to find the 'best' program, but the program that is best for you.

Your Next Step

Recovery is about identifying what works so you can live the life you deserve. If you’re feeling stuck, exploring a different peer support meeting might be the spark you need.

Finding the right recovery community is a lot like finding a therapist or a fitness routine — it’s about the "fit." Because recovery is a deeply personal journey, you have every right to "interview" a group before committing your time and energy to it.

Here is a list of specific questions categorized by the core values mentioned in your journey:

Philosophy and Foundation
These questions help you determine if the group’s core beliefs align with your worldview (secular, spiritual, or scientific).

  1. How does this group view "power"? Does the program emphasize personal empowerment and self-reliance, or does it focus on surrendering to a higher power?
  2. What is the role of spirituality? Is the program strictly secular, or are religious/spiritual practices a requirement for participation?
  3. Is the approach evidence-based? Does the group utilize specific psychological tools, like Cognitive Behavioral Therapy (CBT) or mindfulness-based stress reduction?

Language and Labels
Language can be a powerful tool or a major deterrent. These questions ensure the group's communication style feels respectful to you.

  1. Are specific labels required? Will I be expected to identify as an "addict" or "alcoholic," or is the focus on my current "Sober Self"?
  2. Is the tone focused on "defects" or "strengths"? Does the group spend more time discussing past mistakes and "character flaws," or building future skills and positive self-image?

Meeting Dynamics and Inclusivity
The "vibe" of the meeting is often just as important as the program's literature.

  1. Who is the intended audience? Is this a general group, or is it tailored toward specific demographics (e.g., women-only, LGBTQ+, or secular individuals)?
  2. What is the "crosstalk" policy? Do members interact and give feedback to one another, or is it a "listen-only" format where people share without interruption?
  3. How are different paths to recovery viewed? If I am using Medication-Assisted Treatment (MAT) or attending other types of meetings, will that be supported or criticized?

Structure and Success
These questions help you understand the practical "work" involved in the program.

  1. Is there a formal "step" process? Is there a linear path I must follow, or can I "pick and choose" the tools that work best for me?
  2. What does "success" look like here? Is total abstinence the only goal, or does the group support harm reduction and behavioral changes for various types of habits?

Quick Comparison Checklist

Use this table to keep track of your thoughts after attending an "intro" meeting:

Feature Group A Group B
Felt empowered? Yes  |  No Yes  |  No
Felt engaged? Yes  |  No Yes  |  No
Aligned with personal philosophies? Yes  |  No Yes  |  No
Meeting vibe Calm | Intense | Social Calm | Intense | Social
Overall experience (Rate 1-10) (Rate 1-10)

 

Tips for "Vetting"

  • The Three-Meeting Rule: Try to attend at least three meetings before deciding if a group is for you. Every meeting has a different "flavor" depending on who shows up that day.
  • Look for the "Helpers": Pay attention to the people who have been there a long time. Do you want what they have? If their outlook on life resonates with you, you're likely in the right place.

By presenting these diverse peer support options, we hope to empower individuals to find the right fit for their recovery journey, ultimately increasing their chances of success.

In conclusion, LifeRing is a strong advocate for a more inclusive approach to addiction recovery. We encourage everyone to explore the multitude of peer support groups available and to embrace recovery as a deeply personal journey with a variety of paths to healing and growth.

This January, the U.S. Department of Health and Human Services’ Substance Abuse and Mental Health Services Administration (SAMHSA) is leading a nationwide push to help Americans learn about the importance of Substance Use Disorder (SUD) treatment — with the observance of SUD Treatment Month. You can follow this social media campaign to  help people throughout the United States understand the limitless paths to recovery, the support services that complement treatment, and the importance of having a support system when pursuing recovery: LifeRing Social Media.

 

Orang donation button reading: Support Choice in Recovery

Please click here to support choice in recovery with your donations to LifeRing.

Thank you!